Star Trek Reading Order Header
Order Listing   Title Listing   Comic Box Listings   Group Listings   Story Arc Listings   Character Listings
Enterprise Order  TOS Order  The Lost Era Order  Stargazer Order  TNG Order  Mirror Universe Order
Review Header
 
Review of By the Book
 
Reviewer Rating: Star Wars RatingStar Wars RatingStar Wars RatingStar Wars RatingStar Wars Rating (3)
Avg User Rating: Star Wars RatingStar Wars RatingStar Wars RatingStar Wars RatingStar Wars Rating (3)
Published Date: January 1, 2002
ISBN: 0743448715
 
tstarnes
March 3, 2017
 
By the Book is the first paperback spinning out of Star Trek: Enterprise, if you donít count Broken Bow, which was simple a novelization of the 2 part show opener. Which I donít. I have to say I was surprised by this book. It is far from the best Star Trek title I have read, but it does have one on the most unique angles I have seen so far.

The book is split into two parts; the first part is a first contact with an alien species that goes sideways. The second, and seemingly more important part to the authors, is a role playing game played between five of the crewman that in minor ways affect the first contact plotline.

I have to applaud the authors for trying this. It is a really fresh take on a Star Trek novel. By the time this book came out there were literally hundreds of other books giving us straight ahead Star Trek stories. Honestly it is hard to tell them all apart as they start to run together. If nothing else, the use of a role playing game to counter-balance an otherwise standard plotline is memorable.

Sadly, it didnít completely work from a reading standpoint. The two plots are fairly separate and keep breaking up the momentum of the other plotline. Just as things start to get interesting the book switches plotlines. You end up with reading whiplash.

The rest of the aspects of the book tick off the Star Trek checklist pretty well. Characters are well matched to their TV counterparts and believable. The action, most of which occurs in the role playing game, is fair to middling, but not bad. The one thing I did find weird was the back of the book synopsis doesnít even mention the RPG plotline, which is a full 50% of the book. It only talks about the first contact plot. I guess the marketing team didnít like the idea, but I know I was confused at first by a book that didnít seem to reflect the synopsis.

Overall this is a middle of the road Star Trek book that is memorable more for what it tries to do more than for what it actually accomplishes.
 
 
 
 
Comments
   
 
  There are no comments currently for this title.  
     
     
     

 
 
CMRO Sidebar
Support Star Wars Reading Order

   
Membership Support Us on Amazon
   
Complete Marvel Reading Order
Marvel Cinematic Universe Order
Star Wars Reading Order
Doctor Who Order